The Little Pharisee Within
Television commercials are quite clever. One advertising trick is to get the potential consumer to think of germs and fungi as ugly little creatures that live throughout the body. It depends on the medication being sold where they have set up housekeeping. The ads are effective or they wouldn’t be using them. The invisible is made visible with an accompanying personality. It might also help us to think of some sinful patterns in this way. Anyone who has read the Gospels of the New Testament knows something about the Pharisees. For one thing, as a group, they were treated more severely in Jesus’ teaching than any other. One can almost feel the heat from the rebuke of the Pharisees given by Jesus in Matthew 23. Among other things, they are called blind guides and hypocrites. They are said to be murderers of the prophets and are likened to snakes. This is strong stuff. What made the Pharisees public enemy number one according to Jesus? Before that question can be answered, we will have to recognize a sobering thought. There is a little Pharisee living inside each of us.As a patriotic reaction to the encroachment of Hellenism within Judaism, the Pharisees developed sometime between 140 B.C. and 130 B.C. They were strong advocates of observance of the Mosaic Law and separation from the influences of pagan Greek culture. In order to insure greater loyalty to the law, the Pharisees led the way in developing a system of oral tradition in order to make the law workable in a Greco-Roman world. Their intentions were laudable but quickly created a legalistic system that suffocated mercy and grace within the nation’s spiritual life. A system of oral law began to supersede the true intent of God’s law for Israel. Ritualistic externalism developed within the ranks of the Pharisees. Prayer and giving were done for show. Sabbath observance became encumbered with an endless list of “laws,” such as making it unlawful to carry food from one house to the next, boiling an egg, fixing a leaky water barrel, or having to saddle one’s donkey the day before the Sabbath. These kinds of things were judged as work on the Sabbath. The Pharisees were theologically orthodox within the parameters of Old Testament Judaism, but were hypocritical and bitterly opposed Jesus. They were constantly looking for ways to kill Jesus (Lk. 4:28-30; Jn. 5:16; 8:37). He denounced their standard of righteousness, ostentatious worship, pride, and emphasis on externals while ignoring issues of the heart (Matt. 5:20; 23:5, 6; 9:12; 12:2). It was because the Pharisees had many doctrinal resemblances to that of Jesus that they were rebuked so strongly. The differences were far greater than the similarities and for this reason Jesus declared that “unless your righteousness surpasses that of the scribes and Pharisees, you shall not enter the kingdom of heaven” (Matt. 5:20).
The Christian might be wondering at this point “how could there possibly be a ‘little Pharisee’ dwelling within? Weren’t they hostile to all that Jesus preached?” There lurks in every heart an inclination, a disposition if you will, to exalt outward conformity to rules over justice, mercy, and faithfulness (Matt. 23:23). We can fall into this pattern easily. We can make rules more important than people. We can overlook our own rudeness and sins in our zeal to judge others for what we perceive to be their wrongdoing. Legalism is a very slippery thing. We can say we are against it and even condemn it, while at same time be guilty of it. This is because it comes in different disguises. It can be thinking that makes actions meritorious and the adoption of a bargaining attitude toward God (“If I do this, God has to do that”). It can place acts over and above Scripture with the affect of adhering to man-made do’s and don’t’s as a way of attempting to please God (Matt. 15:1-9). True righteousness ends up being trivialized. For example, rules can be developed that govern dating, clothes, and music and made the measure of who is really committed to God. But being harsh, unmerciful, and judgmental can be excused in the name of a zeal for righteousness. Or someone can think “if I go to the evening service at church instead of watching the ball game, God will bless me this week.” God can never be bought by our behavior. We cannot indebt Him to us because of our performance.
Legalism, that mindset that attempts to use labors done for God to pry favor from God or to escape punishment, is a truth-obscuring and joy-killing monster. It takes our attention off loving service offered to Christ and places it on grim efforts. It brings about conflict and harshness in relationships. The reason for this is that legalism creates an elitist mentality where conformity is demanded and failure is not tolerated (Gal. 5:15, 26). Living in a college dorm with legalists well-distributed around you can be like living in a concentration camp. They are like undercover policemen ready to turn you in for the least little thing. Churches can become joyless places when self-appointed, self-righteous legalists spy out your liberty in Christ (Gal. 2:4; 5:15). You see, legalism is selective in the matters it chooses to promote. It will take parts of God’s law but ignore the rest. It is never consistent. An interesting feature of legalism is not what it forbids, but what it overlooks (Gal. 5:3). The legalist feeds on the idea that he is holding up the high standards of God, when in actuality it is a lower standard. The hoops that he jumps through are doable (a checklist of achievable deeds), but the weightier matters of the law like mercy and loving your enemies are left standing out in the cold.
Where is that little Pharisee? He can rear his ugly little head in our hearts in a minute when a married couple pride themselves in never having been divorced, but yet slice one another to pieces with their tongue, when we feel satisfied for having read our Bible through in a year, but refuse to get involved in the life of an unwed mother in the neighborhood, when we fill our lives with church activities, moral conformity, and great causes, but are unwilling to be reconciled to an offended brother or sister in Christ. Let us make that little Pharisee an unwelcome guest.
Dr. Howard E. Dial
Berachah Bible Church



