If there remains a notion among our churches today that the presence of different generations in them is a bad thing, I would suggest that this wrongheaded idea is nothing more than an invention of church growth experts and pastors driven by an extreme longing to be “seeker sensitive” at the expense of being “gospel-sensitive.” Sadly, the existence of representative generations in our churches is often seen as a hindrance to worship rather than an aid. Multiple services of worship, created for the express purpose of dividing generations along certain worship styles, sometimes emerge as a panacea for such “hindrances.” While this faux division of generations may present a “quick fix,” the prudence of such a decision, in light of the long-term health of the church, is undoubtedly questionable. The urge to press for two or more services, though often well-meaning and sometimes logistically necessary, must be pursued with discernment and caution. At this point, we are unfortunately left with more questions than answers.
When the propriety of generational worship is in view, however, the Bible gives us two overarching reasons why the existence of both young and old generations in the church is both biblical and vital to the strength of the church body. First, God’s Word crosses generations, and second, God is to be our focus in worship, not man.
God-centered worship crosses generations because God’s Word crosses generations. Nowhere in Scripture do we find precedence for separating generations along worship styles. Instead, we find John, in his first epistle, addressing both the young and old in the church, each of whom have different purposes in the church (1 Jn 2:12-14). In addition, we find Peter, addressing the crowd in Jerusalem at Pentecost, proclaiming that the supernatural happenings that they have just witnessed among both the young and old alike were a direct fulfillment of the prophecies of Joel (Acts 2:14-21). It must be noted that, despite being manifested differently (i.e., the young men will see visions and the old men will dream dreams), the outpouring of God’s Spirit is upon both generations, bearing witness to God’s presence among them.
The Bible is also explicit that the passing down of God’s commandments is incumbent upon subsequent generations. In Deuteronomy 6, Moses admonishes the current generation of Israelites to impress God’s word upon the hearts of their children. “And these words that I command you today shall be on your heart. You shall teach them diligently to your children, and shall talk of them when you sit in your house, and when you walk by the way, and when you lie down, and when you rise. You shall bind them as a sign on your hand, and they shall be as frontlets between your eyes. You shall write them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates” (Deut 6:6-9, ESV). Here we see that each generation bears the weight of being faithful with that which God has entrusted to it.
Being trans-generational is in part a celebration of our being fashioned in the very image of God. This glorious truth, however, is only one facet of what it means to enjoy our diversity in Christ. The Bible tells us of a larger body of Christ—Christ’s Bride—which consists of peoples from “every tribe and language and people and nation” who will forever sing, “Worthy is the Lamb, who was slain, to receive power and wealth and wisdom and strength and honor and glory and praise!” (Rev 5:9b; 4:8, NIV) Worship of God is intended not only to transcend generations but to transcend culture. God is not satisfied merely with a sixty-five year old grandmother singing “Great is Thy Faithfulness” alongside a twenty year old college student of the same skin color and cultural upbringing. Sonorous praise offered up with a group of Bosnian refugees in a language completely foreign to one’s ears is likely closer to the Bible’s intent. Embracing a person’s heritage entails more than mere acceptance, it involves participation in his or her culture and heart language.
Not only does God’s Word cross generational boundaries, but God-centered worship has no style or acceptance of a particular generation as its aim. Instead, it seeks only the pleasure and glory of God. The desire to please generations with their particular style of music is inherently flawed in that our hearts are always to be tuned to please God. Anything outside this aim leaves us frustrated and guilty of fueling the idol-making factories of our hearts.
Perhaps you have heard someone quip, “I just can’t worship to this style of music.” The inference is clear: If only they were able to worship utilizing their preferred style of music, God would then be present. Two problems exist at this juncture. First, God is present whether you feel him or not. He is everywhere (Ps 139:7-10; Matt 28:20b). Second, and perhaps more importantly, if the sheer fact that Christ is present in our worship is insufficient cause for spontaneous praise, I would suggest that that person’s preferred form of worship has become an idolatrous breach of the second commandment. Such a statement may simply be an attempt to escape the root problem—a heart problem.
Having been a part of churches that honor both young and old generations and see their gifts in the church as vital to the functioning of the body as a whole, I can attest to their benefit in my own life. There is much wisdom to be gained from the older men and women in the church. Likewise, the younger generations often bring a passion, vitality and a newness in Christ, which serves to ignite evangelistic witness in our churches. Moreover, the church’s testimony to the community needs to be one of unity, a unity that knows no distinction between young and old, Asian or Hispanic, a unity that only makes sense given a Christian worldview. In closing, let us remember that both hymns and modern praise choruses are to be nothing more than an external effort to express an internal devotion. God is most glorified, not with any one generational or ethnic style of music, but with a heart steadfast after him.
Chris Bosson